Using neutral.
- Bengarzy
- Accelerating

- Posts: 107
- Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2018 5:26 pm
- Location: Red Lodge, Suffolk
- Bike(s): BMW R1200 RS
Using neutral.
As I’m checking out the H2 SE as much as poss before buying I have watched loads of vids of road tests, and a lot are in traffic for a lot of the time.........I have yet to see a rider put the bike in neutral at the lights, not one, and it’s for minutes.
It would seem that no one is aware that this causes the clutch to A wear and B get hot if you are in a lot of traffic..doh
The BMW K 1300s we had had a very short clutch life with some riders and never wore at all with others....... guess who was wearing them out
A foot note is needed to also explain that this bike had one of the worst designed and operating clutches I have ever seen, it drags badly on them all, judders on quick take off and makes a horrible sqwauk at the same time. Another reason I am returning to Japanese made bikes.
It would seem that no one is aware that this causes the clutch to A wear and B get hot if you are in a lot of traffic..doh
The BMW K 1300s we had had a very short clutch life with some riders and never wore at all with others....... guess who was wearing them out
A foot note is needed to also explain that this bike had one of the worst designed and operating clutches I have ever seen, it drags badly on them all, judders on quick take off and makes a horrible sqwauk at the same time. Another reason I am returning to Japanese made bikes.
0 x
- Snakes709
- Supercharged!

- Posts: 1399
- Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2018 2:42 am
- Location: Edmonton, AB
- Bike(s): 2018 H2 SX SE
- x 11
- x 394
Re: Using neutral.
I use neutral all the time when its worth it. If I come up to a light and I know its about to change, ill leave it in gear. I edited this video for the retard running the red light but I was sitting at that light for a few minutes as I caught the yellow when I got there. Not gonna sit in gear the entire time.
0 x
2018 H2 SX/SE
-ZX10R Headers
-2016+ ZX10R Yoshimura Alpha 3/4 system
-Sprint P08 Filter
-Vcyclenut flash
-Driven block off plates
-Yager Werx Intercooler
Re: Using neutral.
Is it bad only if you are moving some or even just stopped completely still with the clutch pulled in it's bad? I didn't know. On my versys 1000 I always found it easier to have the clutch pulled in than fuck with the foot work. (Occasionally I've had issues popping back into 1st from neutral especially if I've rolled a smidgeon.)
Similiarly. I thought I was told on newer bikes it's not an issue, but what about coasting clutch in vs always engine braking? Coming from a car it took me a while to accept engine braking but now I use it quite a bit with occasional downshifts as I coast into lights basically. Which is better the engine working to slow the bike vs just pulling the clutch in and say coasting down a bit paired with mild braking the whole way. (and tapping some down shifts on the way just so you are in right gear in case you suddenly need to go.)
Similiarly. I thought I was told on newer bikes it's not an issue, but what about coasting clutch in vs always engine braking? Coming from a car it took me a while to accept engine braking but now I use it quite a bit with occasional downshifts as I coast into lights basically. Which is better the engine working to slow the bike vs just pulling the clutch in and say coasting down a bit paired with mild braking the whole way. (and tapping some down shifts on the way just so you are in right gear in case you suddenly need to go.)
0 x
- Snakes709
- Supercharged!

- Posts: 1399
- Joined: Sun Aug 19, 2018 2:42 am
- Location: Edmonton, AB
- Bike(s): 2018 H2 SX SE
- x 11
- x 394
Re: Using neutral.
Its not an issue at all. The clutches are soaked in oil and there is barely enough engine speed/load on them to put any wear.
0 x
2018 H2 SX/SE
-ZX10R Headers
-2016+ ZX10R Yoshimura Alpha 3/4 system
-Sprint P08 Filter
-Vcyclenut flash
-Driven block off plates
-Yager Werx Intercooler
- JonTheChron
- Supercharged!

- Posts: 539
- Joined: Sun Dec 10, 2017 9:00 pm
- Location: Quebec
- Bike(s): H2 SX SE '18
- x 7
- x 6
Re: Using neutral.
I'm wondering how much wear is put on the clutch by using launch control, humm
0 x
2018 H2 SX SE (1st in Canada)
2011 Ninja 1000 (sold)
2009 Ninja 250R (sold)
- stk0308
- Accelerating

- Posts: 214
- Joined: Wed Feb 14, 2018 7:37 pm
- Location: St Louis
- Bike(s): '01 YZ426f, '20 Tiger 900 Rally, '16 Street Triple R, '18 H2 SX SE
- x 22
- x 6
Re: Using neutral.
I almost never take a bike out of gear, unless I know the light is going to be REALLY long. 45k miles on a '99 Sprint ST. 98k miles on an '02 Sprint ST. 76k miles on an '08 Sprint ST. All miles mine, and all still had their original clutches when the left me. The '02 I saw the clutch myself, it still had plenty of meat on it. I'm not worried.
0 x
Motorcycling is not, of itself, inherently dangerous. It is, however, extremely unforgiving of inattention, ignorance, incompetence, or stupidity
- XcelleraThor
- Supercharged!

- Posts: 261
- Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2018 8:38 pm
- Location: Deutschland (Germany)
- Bike(s): '22 H2 SX SE
- x 181
- x 69
Re: Using neutral.
Because I hate the BANG, when shifting into 1st gear from neutral on my SE.
I simply shift down slowly when aproaching a red light and stay in 1st, after having come to a stop. I have somehow gotten used to doing this on all my former bikes and compared to the BANG (yes caps here, again) with my SE, shifting into 1st from neutral on the CBR600 was a whisper. And thinking back, that I even didn't like, didn't have the comparison at that time, though.
I keep the clutch pulled as much/often as I can on the SE, especially when the engine is (still) cold.
I simply shift down slowly when aproaching a red light and stay in 1st, after having come to a stop. I have somehow gotten used to doing this on all my former bikes and compared to the BANG (yes caps here, again) with my SE, shifting into 1st from neutral on the CBR600 was a whisper. And thinking back, that I even didn't like, didn't have the comparison at that time, though.
I keep the clutch pulled as much/often as I can on the SE, especially when the engine is (still) cold.
0 x
CB250N (long gone) --- XJ600 (unforgotten) --- CBR600F4 (honorably discharged) --- '18 H2SXSE (GatewayDrug) --- '22 H2SXSE (NewQueen)
- Gadus
- Accelerating

- Posts: 121
- Joined: Fri May 04, 2018 8:09 am
- Location: Norway
- Bike(s): H2 SX SE
- x 1
Re: Using neutral.
I totally agree. I don't like the bang from the gearbox when engaging 1st gear, and especially not when cold. The engine idles very high when cold, so if I don't have the time to let it stand running in neutral, I start it in 1st gear with the clutch pulled and ride off right away.XcelleraThor wrote: Mon Dec 03, 2018 11:22 pm Because I hate the BANG, when shifting into 1st gear from neutral on my SE.
I simply shift down slowly when aproaching a red light and stay in 1st, after having come to a stop. I have somehow gotten used to doing this on all my former bikes and compared to the BANG (yes caps here, again) with my SE, shifting into 1st from neutral on the CBR600 was a whisper. And thinking back, that I even didn't like, didn't have the comparison at that time, though.
I keep the clutch pulled as much/often as I can on the SE, especially when the engine is (still) cold.
On my former BMW's I was used to severe BANGS when shifting from neutral to 1st gear, so I was looking forward to a smoother gearshift on the SX SE. A friend with a ZZR1400 told me the gearbox on the Kawis were as smooth as butter. I was disappointed........ (But that is the only issue with the bike)
At red lights I normally stop with the clutch pulled and in 1st gear. The clucth will take no harm.
0 x
- Burmashave
- Supercharged!

- Posts: 542
- Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2018 8:59 pm
- Location: USA
- Bike(s): H2 SX SE
- x 16
- x 11
Re: Using neutral.
On my H2, I rarely shift into neutral at intersections. I find that hitting neutral on my H2 is a bit finnicky. Mebbe it'll get better when I switch to full synth oil.
On my Versys 1k, I do it more often, mostly because the Versys has a neutral finder (with the bike stopped, a full upshift from 1st shifts into neutral instead of 2nd gear). A gearbox with neutral finder is one of those features that you don't think much about when you buy the bike, but then you get used to it and miss it when it's gone. It's not only easier to pop it into neutral at intersections, but it's also convenient when starting the parked bike for warmup -- just reach down with my hand and pop the shifter hard up into neutral -- no fiddling and no doubt about hitting it. The Versys is also smoother going from N to 1st.
On my Versys 1k, I do it more often, mostly because the Versys has a neutral finder (with the bike stopped, a full upshift from 1st shifts into neutral instead of 2nd gear). A gearbox with neutral finder is one of those features that you don't think much about when you buy the bike, but then you get used to it and miss it when it's gone. It's not only easier to pop it into neutral at intersections, but it's also convenient when starting the parked bike for warmup -- just reach down with my hand and pop the shifter hard up into neutral -- no fiddling and no doubt about hitting it. The Versys is also smoother going from N to 1st.
0 x
- Bengarzy
- Accelerating

- Posts: 107
- Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2018 5:26 pm
- Location: Red Lodge, Suffolk
- Bike(s): BMW R1200 RS
Re: Using neutral.
Ok, a multi plate wet clutch consists of at least 12 plates, half driven and half driving, when clutch is pulled in there is just a few thou of gap between each plate (if you’re lucky) and they are wet with oil, the drag from the plates wobbling unsupported gives clutch drag and is the reason it clonks going back into gear and also why a multi plate clutch gets hot in traffic if you don’t use neutral when crossing town....... this makes the clonk going into neutral worse when you do bother to use neutral and go back into first.
.....BMW will NOT replace a worn out clutch under warranty as it is called “abuse” not wear and it’s caused primarily on the K 1300 by not selecting neutral.........and also because of the faults in the design but it does prove that some wet clutches are more prone to excessive wear than others due to waiting at lights or junctions with the clutch in... Japanese clutches and transmissions are also way better than the Germans too
.....BMW will NOT replace a worn out clutch under warranty as it is called “abuse” not wear and it’s caused primarily on the K 1300 by not selecting neutral.........and also because of the faults in the design but it does prove that some wet clutches are more prone to excessive wear than others due to waiting at lights or junctions with the clutch in... Japanese clutches and transmissions are also way better than the Germans too
0 x
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 11 guests

